Safety is one of the most important criteria road traffic... The device of the car is designed in such a way as to make driving Vehicle absolutely for all sources of motion. The clear glass increases the driver's visibility many times over and makes the assessment traffic situation more objective.
TOP of the best car wipers of 2019.
What role do windshield wipers play and how to choose them
Both in winter and in all months of summer, it is simply impossible to move without wipers, frost, rain, water from puddles and mud make movement difficult. However, there are some tricks even in the process of choosing wipers. First of all, they are divided into winter and summer according to the characteristics of the material for manufacture. So, the main criteria by which car wipers are selected are:
- production material and seasonality;
- the length of each brush (values may vary);
- mounting and fixing options;
- selling price.
Frame, frameless and hybrids - their features
There is a traditional classification, according to which wipers are usually divided into frame and frameless. The first are the most common and function as follows: A system of balanced rocker arms, hinged, ensures a tight fit of the rubber blade to the surface. The main advantage of the design is its low price. But over time, the fasteners loosen, and the rubber bands no longer give tight contact, and in winter they are highly susceptible to freezing. Their counterparts became more effective, but they were no longer made of metal, but of plastic. They are easier to clean, and the rocker arms are more precise and more rigidly connected. All this has found expression in a more effective cleaning of car windshields.
In contrast to them, the so-called "frameless" are a spoiler-holder made of rubber and plastic. The top summer wipers include a lot of such models, because they do not have wear-out hinges, but the design and icing. The glass is cleaned by a rubber blade that is placed between a pair of thin metal plates. Other benefits include the following:
- the structure is not skewed;
- the movement of the brushes is almost noiseless;
- When the rubber blade is erased, it can be easily replaced without having to re-design.
While frameless is resistant to icing, it is not as versatile as wireframe models. Their springy stripes must exactly follow the curvature. windshield, therefore, when buying such structures, they must be selected for a specific car model. Manufacturers of windshield wipers took into account the shortcomings of each of the designs and developed the so-called "hybrids". A traditional rocker arm frame with hinges works in tandem with a plastic spoiler. Unlike conventional wireframes, hybrid ones are smaller in size. However, they retained the main advantage of frameless models, namely the aerodynamic effect, due to which the level of pressure on the glass surface increases.
It is also worth noting the tight fit of the blades, which is so difficult to achieve on cars with convex windshields or on the rear windows of hatchbacks and station wagons. Such designs are not cheap in car dealerships, but they retain the elasticity, resilience and working qualities of rubber edges for many months of service. Each driver decides which firm of wipers to choose for his car according to his own consumer preferences. We must also remember that there are different ways their fastenings. Different manufacturers began to make them unique about 20 years ago, abandoning the unified fastening system that existed earlier. To install them on as many car models as possible, manufacturers complete the products with special adapters.
Rating of the most successful models of wipers for cars
Among the best wiper blades in this rating are exactly those that have been tested by thousands of users in terms of operation. This is confirmed by the numerous reviews that are in the free access of the Internet space.
Some of the most demanded and respected products of this product group. For the manufacture of a metal frame, galvanized steel is used, which is reliable. Another distinctive feature is that such wipers adhere very well to the surface of the windshield, even when driving at high speed. Replacing a worn-out rubber band will not take much time, since the locking mechanism itself is simple and extremely reliable. There are practically no disadvantages of this product, but among the advantages, users note:
- orientation towards use in different climatic regions, even in the most severe;
- good adherence to the glass surface;
- the ability to use on different brands of cars due to the complete set of several adapters;
- an affordable selling price for many consumers.
It is no coincidence that the products of the French manufacturer were included in the list of "best wipers for a car", because they are traditionally famous for their long and reliable operation. With its help, the driver does not have to puzzle over at what point in time it is necessary to change worn-out rubber bands, because the product is equipped with an automatic wear control option. In addition, it is designed to operate in various climatic conditions: from heat to extreme cold. The assortment of the dimensional grid will delight the owners of a wide variety of car brands - it has products with a length of 24 to 80 cm.The following advantages are offered by this manufacturer of wiper blades:
- a good choice based on size;
- lack of noise during operation;
- high-quality cleaning and adherence to the windshield at high speeds;
- availability of additional options in the form of a wear measurement sensor.
One of the best summer wipers for modern vehicles, featuring a high degree of innovation. Developed by American designers, they are perfectly combined with any type of windshield, of any degree of curvature. They perfectly cope with the function of cleaning from dirt and water in different weather and operate almost silently. High-quality removal from dirt and sediments is achieved by applying a Teflon coating. Even when driving at a speed of 200 km / h, these products have demonstrated tremendous efficiency. The manufacturer has provided reliable fasteners, thanks to which the brushes are well fixed without scratching the glass surface. Despite the large number of advantages, the main disadvantage of the product is its rather high retail price.
Good car wipers with many auxiliary options. Firstly, the replacement of rubber bands is not a particularly troublesome task, and, secondly, the frame of the structure is made of stainless steel. The manufacturer made sure that each of the parts fit snugly to all the others. For this reason, it was possible to achieve a high cleaning ability and a long service life. This design was also included in the list of leaders due to the fact that natural rubber is used in the brushes. They also have special inserts that make it possible to clean the glass even when driving at high speed. The wipers are easy to install, efficiently remove all kinds of dirt and are versatile across a wide range of car brands. Particular attention should be paid to the wear of rubber bands that are made on the basis of natural rubber.
Excellent construction for use during the winter months of the year. The aerodynamic shape is designed to be one of the the best wipers for cars in 2019 and easily cope with windshield frosting even in harsh climates. Users note the corrosion resistance of the material from which they are made. The graphite coating is designed to reduce operating noise. The design is designed to provide good contact, which is essential when driving at high speeds.
The rubber inserts, which are an integral part of wiper blades, can be replaced by yourself in a matter of minutes. Tests over many months of operation allow us to conclude about durability and high reliability. One of the most important advantages of the product: application on all brands of cars due to the fact that the kit includes a universal adapter. The disadvantages include the rigid form of the structure, which is not very effective on very curved glass. In list strengths note:
- acceptable purchase price;
- effective cleaning of the surface from dirt and water;
- versatility for different brands machines.
Some of the best representatives of the rating of car wipers for 2019. For a relatively attractive price, you can buy very high quality windshield wipers for every day. The metal frame is rustproof, powerful and practical. Very good quality cleaning gums made from natural rubber - they will successfully cope with dirt and heavy pouring rains. The manufacturer processes the product with special compounds that extend its service life. If necessary, a removable elastic band can be easily removed, and an unworn one is put in its place. This design behaves better in the warm season, and for severe weather, you can choose a more efficient product.
And again the traditional European quality for which the eminent manufacturer has become famous. This is a classic "skeleton", but it has a specific difference. It's all about the gum, which consists of 2 components. The one inside the other is softer. This ensures a smooth ride and smooth operation of the wipers. The harder outer gum removes any debris from the glass surface well. The main advantages of this model can be represented by the following list:
- decent quality of cleaning at high speed of the car;
- efficient operation over several seasons;
- effective cleaning due to the fact that the gum consists of 2 different components;
- targeting specific brands of vehicles;
- a spoiler protects the brush and improves its performance.
Those who are not indifferent to high standards of European quality at a fairly affordable cost should pay attention to this model. Cleaning the glass will delight even the fastidious drivers, because the gum is covered with graphite and adheres perfectly to the glass. Thanks to a special adapter, such a wiper can be attached to any vehicle. Long service life is guaranteed by the frameless design. She does not care about strong winds, pouring rain and high speed of the car - in all cases, the wiper will cope with its tasks "perfectly". The manufacturer declares that its product is resistant to ultraviolet rays, temperature extremes and is designed to operate throughout the entire calendar year. The main positive aspects of using Alca Super Flat:
- sales prevalence and versatility;
- high-quality glass cleaning and preservation of characteristics at any temperature;
- does not freeze and takes good care of the glass surface.
Experts call the only drawback the difficulty of replacing separately purchased rubber bands.
These are the frame wiper blades, which are best suited for cleaning glass at all speeds due to graphite spraying. High wear resistance and strength are another of their key characteristics. If the car does not provide for special mounts for frame or frameless brushes, the choice of such a design may be the best solution. Car owners note its light weight and almost complete absence of noise during operation. Do-it-yourself installation does not require special skills. At the same time, the average period of operation reaches 15-18 months. The design itself is designed to ensure a perfect fit to the windshield. The package includes a manual for the user in Russian.
Which wipers are the best in the premium model category? You can pay attention to this type of frameless type product. They performed well in a wide variety of speed modes and always confidently cope with pollution of the highest complexity. A special adapter makes the installation process easier, but the brushes themselves lie well on the glass surface, practically without creating extraneous noise. The robust design of this model assumes a service life of 1.5 years or more. Graphite-coated brushes work quietly and efficiently, and they can also be used in regions with cold winters and frosts. Also worth noting is the high build quality of their design.
Any change in weather conditions will cease to be an unpleasant surprise if you update the windshield wipers on your car in advance. The above rating includes the best models of 2019, from which you can choose by affordable price the design that will be most effective based on the customer's requirements.
Much has changed since the introduction of the first cars. Vehicle windshields began to be produced in larger sizes, their curvature increased. The length of the wiper blades has grown. Windshield wipers began to be made differently. In their design, there is now more swing, providing better pressure on the glass. Sometimes the changes made by manufacturers have a bad effect on aerodynamic performance, structural reliability, visibility deteriorates, and the wipers' work becomes more noisy.
Frameless wiper blades were introduced in the 1980s. They had the same convex shape as the windshield. The metal spring elements are curved. The brushes were made wider and stiffer. Thanks to this design, the engineers solved the problem of uniform pressing of the blade around the entire perimeter of the wiper. The supporting element of the structure was an evodium or steel plate. It has a precise geometric shape, firmly presses the brush to the glass along its entire length.
Sale
Features and Benefits of Frameless Wiper Blades
For the manufacture of frameless wiper blades, manufacturers use high-quality materials, innovative technologies, which provide excellent consumer properties and a long service life. In order to improve the quality of glass cleaning, the cleaning edges should be evenly pressed along their entire length. This was achieved by bending the springy strips.
In the Valeo Silencio X-Trm premium wiper blades, the spring element bends in accordance with the curvature of the windshield of each specific vehicle brand for which they are made. Excellent aerodynamic performance is achieved by the invention of a smaller, monolithic brush. This figure is significantly lower than that of conventional wipers. This reduces the pressure of the air stream pressing the wiper away from the windshield. 
Some models of wipers have a spoiler, as the curved profile of the brush is called in a special way. It increases the downforce when the vehicle picks up high speed. This is important for swing wipers. They are installed on Peugeot 307, Honda Civic, Citroen C4 Picasso. Two brushes resist the flow of air at the same time. Frameless wipers contribute to significant noise reduction. At a speed of 120 km / h, this figure will be only two decibels.
The frameless brush is almost ice-free. In the usual design of the janitor, the water in the swing joints always froze, and they ceased to lie tightly on the glass, leaving streaks, streaks of dirt. Thanks to the low profile of the frameless brush, such effects were avoided. The high popularity of frameless wipers is confirmed by numerous positive reviews vehicle owners and experts.
Best sellers
Integrated spoiler
In conventional brushes, the spoiler played the role of a windage compensator. Without it, they started jumping on the glass when the car picked up a high speed. The design of the frameless brushes has a lower profile than that of the frame models, but manufacturers still equip them with an integrated spoiler. It has excellent aerodynamic performance.
The integrated spoiler is available in symmetrical and asymmetrical versions. This is an important indicator. Wipers with an asymmetric spoiler, such as Bosch Aerotwin, are characterized by increased downforce. They are designed to work at high speeds. The brushes with the symmetrical spoiler have less downforce, but they are versatile. They are installed on vehicles with a right-hand drive and a wiper swing system.
Brush wear indicator
Frameless brushes can be equipped with a wear indicator, for example SWF wipers. This refers to the permanent paint mark on the wiper. It is clearly visible to the driver. When installing the brushes, do not forget to remove the protective film from the indicator. It will change its color over time, which signals the need to change the wipers. Their wear is influenced by the weather, bright sunlight, operating time and some other factors. 
What the future holds for frameless wiper models
Frameless brushes have replaced lower quality designs. They ensure perfect cleaning of even heavily curved glass in most modern vehicle brands. They have excellent aerodynamic performance. They are installed on expensive, executive cars. They have formed a price affordable to everyone. Most manufacturers today complete their cars with frameless brushes when they are manufactured. Therefore, they have a great future.
The most famous manufacturers of frameless wipers
The majority of manufacturers have mastered the technology of manufacturing frameless wipers. To trade confidently, they bet on modern equipment and high quality. The stores also sell copies of the most successful development models.
It should be borne in mind that the quality of no-name frameless windshield wipers will always be lower than that of well-known brands that care about their reputation. Manufacturers known all over the world have developed trade networks and many distributors. They regularly receive feedback from customers, which gives them the opportunity to continually improve the quality of their wipers.
Brand known to many vehicle owners Aerotwin produced by the company Bosch... These frameless wipers are characterized as reliable and durable. They are equipped with a spoiler of excellent quality. They are installed on any cars, because they are equipped with different types fastening.
Aerotwin can be sold as a set or as a single hook brush. Bosch produces various modifications of wipers. The popular Multi-Clip series are single brushes with a universal adapter for unusual attachments. They are very high quality. These wipers will not fit the hook mount. 
Company Valeo manufactures frameless brushes under the brands Valeo, SWF and PJ. PJ products are not widely used. Wipers Valeo, SWF are widely represented on Russian market... The most famous series of frameless models of the company's brushes:
- inexpensive modifications of Valeo Compact Evolution and Compact Revolution. Evolution model is characterized by the presence of a special type of fastening, supplied in the kit. Revolution are brushes with standard hook attachment. They are sold one at a time.
- Valeo Silencio X-trm premium models are tailor-made, delivered in two.
- SWF Visionext- this is the modern generation of wipers. They are designed taking into account the latest technological solutions. They are inexpensive, different high quality and reliability. They have a symmetrical spoiler, so the brushes can be fitted on right-hand drive vehicles. Supplied one at a time.
- premium SWF Visioflex brushes are sold in pairs. They are made taking into account the special curvature of the glass.
British company
Driving a car should be, first of all, safe for the driver himself, and for passengers, and for other road users. In this matter, there are no trifles at all, the wiper blades play an important role - their choice should be approached carefully and thoughtfully. They can be divided into two large groups - summer and winter. Winter ones have good elasticity due to the use of rather soft rubber. In order for the installed products to be perfect, a number of important criteria are taken into account when purchasing them:
- The versatility of the fastening method;
- Right and left brush length;
- The material from which the structure is made;
- Price.
There are three main types of wipers on the market today: frame, frameless and hybrid.
The first type is found quite often, the products fit tightly to the glass, which can be achieved due to the systematic functioning of the rocker arms with hinges. All main moving parts are made of high quality plastic. The material is almost not covered with ice in the cold, easily removes snow, water and dirt from the glass surface. The price for them is quite low, but such brushes will not last too long. Literally after a couple of seasons, they work worse, begin to creak and move away from the plane of the glass, due to which streaks of dirt are formed.
Frameless wipers are similar in structure to a spoiler made of plastic and rubber. It has two metal plates inside. A rubber blade is fixed between them, which will clean the glass. There is a mounting bracket in the center, and the ends are covered with plugs to resist icing. During operation, the products practically do not emit extraneous noise. If necessary, the rubber insert can be replaced.
Hybrid wipers are able to adapt to any glass shape. The structure frame is located inside the cowl-fairing, the product is able to withstand any loads well, reliably removes all contaminants that interfere with the view, and have a long service life.
When compiling a rating of the top 10 best wiper blades, we took into account the ratio of price and quality of products, took into account user reviews. We hope our review will help you choose the most suitable brushes that will last a long time and reliably.
Rating of the best models of wipers in 2019
This is one of the latest premium models. They perfectly clean glass, behave well in the speed range up to 190 km / h. The products are frameless, which ensures their low weight, they adhere well to the windshield, during operation they do not emit extraneous sounds... The design provides a special universal adapter to facilitate installation.
The frame is made of high quality plastic that can withstand low and high temperatures well. The products are very reliable, due to which it is possible to achieve the same functionality and performance as those of the native brushes that came with the new car. Average service life is in the range from 10 to 18 months, the brush itself is equipped with graphite spraying.
Advantages:
- Perfectly adheres to the glass surface;
- Does not make noise during operation;
- High quality build.
Disadvantages:
- After about 8 months, the fasteners begin to loosen, which is why the brushes move away from the glass and perform their function worse.
9. Trico Exactfit
This device is equipped with a metal frame and a graphite-coated brush. The brushes are durable and wear-resistant. Small slots are provided in the metal of the case, which significantly reduces the weight of the structure. They are well suited for cars where there is no mount for frameless or hybrid products, they are good at cleaning the windshield at almost any car speed.
The brushes weigh a little, due to which they emit a minimum amount of noise during operation. Fastens securely to prevent theft. Installation is very simple, you can do it yourself, moreover, the kit includes clear instructions in Russian. The average product life is 8 to 16 months.
Advantages:
- Attaches to the glass as tightly as possible;
- Able to serve for several seasons;
- The brushes are attached as securely as possible.
Disadvantages:
- Despite the universal size, they are not suitable for every car.
It is a classic frame construction with excellent quality. The main distinguishing characteristic of the product is the two-component rubber of the brush: in the inner part there is a softer material. It allows you to significantly reduce the noise emitted during operation, and also ensures a smooth and uniform movement of the product.
The working edge is made of harder materials that easily remove all unnecessary from the glass surface, moreover, due to such rubber, it is possible to significantly extend the life of the structure.
Advantages:
- The brushes are made of two-component rubber, which easily removes any kind of dirt;
- On sale you can find models designed for specific car brands;
- Very high quality workmanship;
- Can last for several seasons;
- Some designs have a spoiler that will have a positive effect on the performance of the brushes, especially when driving at high speeds.
Disadvantages:
- The edge, made of hard rubber, breaks down quickly enough - it is erased, cracked, and so on.
These are reliable and high-quality products of the European level, which are distinguished by quite acceptable prices. The rubber insert, which adjoins directly to the windshield, is covered with a graphite compound. This allows it to cope even better with intense precipitation, to protect the glass from icing. The rubber also contains fine tourmaline, which prevents the formation of an oil film.
The set includes one blade and an adapter that allows you to install it on any type of wiper mount. The product is frameless, which ensures a long service life of the product. The brush reliably adheres to the glass even at high speed and in a headwind, because of it there is no additional resistance.
It is universal, due to which it is allowed to install it both on left-hand drive cars and on cars with right-hand drive. The brush will provide comfortable view driver in any weather conditions, it can be used in warm and cold seasons, the cost is quite acceptable.
Advantages:
- Does not freeze;
- Copes with any weather conditions;
- Reliably cleans the glass, giving the driver a full view;
- They are quite widespread - you can find them in almost every car store and even at gas stations;
- All-season products;
- Long service life;
- No streaks or scratches on the glass.
Disadvantages:
- Not suitable for BMW vehicles;
- If you purchase gum separately, then inserting them can be problematic.
These are some of the best winter brushes in the economical price range. The design provides for a reliable metal frame, and the workmanship is very high. The elastic band at the brush is made of natural rubber using molding technology.
There are no irregularities on the working surface, which greatly improves the quality of cleaning the surface of the windshield from various contaminants. The frame is treated with a powder paint composition, which reliably protects products from the occurrence of corrosive processes.
Advantages:
- Low cost;
- Excellent working qualities;
- The elastic is made from natural rubber;
- The elastic can be replaced if necessary.
Disadvantages:
- Behaves badly in winter period is not recommended for use at this time.
The brushes are specially designed for use in the cold season. The structure combines the aerodynamic design of frameless products and reliable contact with the glass. This model perfectly cleans glass even at high speeds due to the increased pressure contact. The product is covered with a layer of graphite, which reduces the amount of noise emitted.
In production, polymeric materials are used that are not subject to corrosion. The rubber insert itself is replaceable; it has passed a number of tests that have proven its reliability and durability. The kit includes a universal adapter that allows you to install brushes on any car model.
Advantages:
- Quite reasonable price;
- Good cleaning performance;
- The mount fits all vehicles.
Disadvantages:
- Due to the rigid shape of the brushes, they are not tightly pressed against all car windows.
These brushes combine all the most modern technologies associated with the production of such products. They were developed by American engineers using frameless technology. The products will perfectly get rid of water and dirt even on the most curved windshields, while at the same time it will firmly press against the glass surface. It works quite quietly, the vibration level is reduced. Brushes are well suited for Russian climatic conditions, as they will behave well at temperatures from -40 to +60 degrees. They work efficiently at vehicle speeds up to 190 km / h.
The cleaning element is Teflon coated. It prevents scratches on the windshield surface and removes all dirt. The fastening of the product is elongated, which allows you to achieve the most uniform pressure on the glass. The brushes are universal, they are suitable even for right-hand drive cars equipped with the so-called swing glass cleaning system.
Advantages:
- Silent operation;
- Teflon coated cleaning element;
- Uniform and high-quality cleaning.
Disadvantages:
- Quite high cost.
Such brushes represent a hybrid design, which differs from analogs in a number of performance characteristics. The basis of the product is a stainless steel frame, the rubber bands are replaceable, the mechanics are of very high quality, due to which these brushes are one of the best among those on the domestic market.
Natural rubber is used in the manufacture of the product, so the period of operation becomes much longer. The design has low-profile inserts that make the height of the brush to a minimum, they also allow the brushes to additionally press against the glass and provide optimal air flow. All parts of the brush are tightly fitted to each other - this improves the quality of glass cleaning and significantly extends the service life of the product.
Advantages:
- Perfectly fits most car stacks;
- Easy to install;
- Thoroughly removes moisture and dirt from the glass surface.
Disadvantages:
- Rubber inserts are made from natural rubber and wear off quickly.
The main distinguishing quality of these French-made brushes is the presence of a wear sensor - the motorist will immediately see when they need to be replaced.
There are many sizes - from 24 to 80 cm. The workmanship is high, the brushes can withstand temperature extremes and exposure to ultraviolet rays. They can be used in any climatic conditions at any time of the year.
Advantages:
- The brushes are equipped with wear sensors;
- During operation, they emit a minimum amount of noise;
- Thoroughly clean glass even at high speed;
- Large range of sizes.
Disadvantages:
- High price.
Winter. It is a rare day in our latitudes without having to use the windshield wipers on the trip. Now a blizzard, then a thaw with rain. On the highways, oily soil suspension, in cities, liquid acid-salty porridge in any weather ... Therefore, we continued to test the wiper blades, paying close attention to the models recommended for winter.
In the cold season, windshield wipers have a hard time: frozen water in all its variety is no better than a myriad of insects and sticky seeds. The falling snow freezes on the working brushes into an ice block, and on the cooling glass during the stay it manages to form a strong translucent shell. Frost after a damp thaw adheres to death the rubber bands of the wipers to the surface, so much so that their edge can come off the base if you try to tear them off by force.
But how are special Winter tires, so there are also special winter brushes, which should be more resistant to the vagaries of the weather. They use frost-resistant rubber grades that better retain elasticity at minus, and hide the elastic frame vulnerable to ice. But how much help these tricks, and which option is better for a motorist?
To figure it out, we took five popular models of brushes from among those recommended for the cold season, differing in price level and design, and went to travel on winter roads. Test Car Same As Fall - Toyota Land cruiser with an angle of inclination of the windshield 52 degrees to the horizon. The size of the brushes is 40 cm, the attachment is a hook. The state of the glass remained the same, that is, without abrasions and with three small chips. So we have the opportunity to correctly compare the behavior of the new tested brushes with those that participated in the autumn tests.
The end of the October tests unexpectedly fell on a sudden sharp cold snap with abundant snow, which made it possible to imagine how the experimental specimens would behave in winter. Snowfall was not included in the mandatory program, but it made it possible to feel the effectiveness of the subjects in the entire range of weather conditions. The result was predictable: wet snow adhered to all models, but the frame ones lost their performance much earlier than the frameless and hybrid ones. Despite the giant snow build-ups on either side of the working rubber, the last two continued and continued to clean. This prompted the idea of using the Denso hybrid brushes, which became the absolute leader of the autumn tests, in the winter tests. And to them add two frameless models: comparable in price and the most expensive, two classic winter models in a protective case, expensive and cheap.
Our candidates
Denso wiper blade
The range of prices for models suitable for winter turned out to be less than for summer ones. First of all, by reducing the low-cost segment. Last time most expensive hybrid Denso wiper blade this time it was in the middle of the list, practically unchanged in price. At the heart of its design is a double-hinged metal frame, covered from above with a plastic spoiler of three movably connected parts. It is hingedly connected to the frame elements and tightly covers the mechanism from dirt and adhering snow flying from the outside, although it does not give tightness. In addition, the spoiler is designed to more tightly press the brush against the glass with an incoming air stream at high speeds. The brush is made neatly, gracefully, and at the same time massive. Fastening only for a hook, structurally changing the adapter is impossible.
Valeo first
The same money costs frameless Valeo first, the lightest among the subjects, but ... looking more massive than the similar in design and objectively heavier Bosch model. From the outside, the frameless Valeo looks solid, but it has a soft outer rubber cover, loosely fitting elastic metal elements and consisting of two parts. The “Shelter” is not completely airtight, although it does not leave any gaps. A sharp ridge along the upper surface serves to enhance aerodynamic pressure on the glass. The universal attachment point with interchangeable adapters in the kit allows you to use these brushes on a huge number of cars. Moreover, standard sizes seat make it possible to use adapters of other brands, if necessary, and easily install these brushes on almost any machine.
Bosch Aerotwin
The most expensive model with a margin of two hundred rubles from the second place this time was a frameless brush Bosch Aerotwin from the brand's flagship line. Outwardly and structurally, it is very similar to Valeo, but the outer shell is stiffer here, although in the same way it consists of two parts and has mobility. The firm appears to be deliberately withholding details of the materials the brush is made of. On the official website, there are only streamlined references to the wear-resistant working edge coating and two-component elastic band. In the same place, it is stated in plain text: "the ice does not freeze to the brush." Well, this is already interesting. Despite the fact that the attachment point with interchangeable adapters is made differently than that of Valeo, it is also freely compatible with all "Boshevsky" adapters from brushes of any series. But to install adapters from competitors, a slight modification will be required, after which it will be possible to install frameless Bosch through almost any adapter.
Champion winter
Winter brushes packed in soft covers took the lower price segment... The protected frame structure was invented specifically for winter conditions, so the height of the working rubber is twice as high as that of summer and all-season models - this makes it easier to deal with snowdrifts sticking to the glass and self-cleaning from ice. One of the most popular and expensive brushes of this design is Champion winter... Surprisingly, the USA is marked as the country of production on their packaging. This is probably why this model is longer than the rest: the Americans do not have the metric system, and 16 inches is still almost 41 cm. The Champion is even lighter than Denso and a little heavier than frameless models. The smooth rubber of the cover is not the most pleasant to the touch and smell, so even for a moment there is a doubt about the origin of the product. But it is scattered by solid rivets and impeccable execution of the metal fastener. By the way, any adapters from Champion frame brushes and most competing brands are suitable for it.
Mega power
The cheapest model in the current testing, as well as in the autumn, is represented by the brand Mega power... Then the brushes of this Russian-Chinese brand showed themselves surprisingly well and became the leaders in terms of price-quality ratio. Judging by what is felt under the cover, inside the winter model there is the same frame with double hinges as in the summer model. At the same time, the rubber of the cover itself is a little rough and pleasant to the touch, the tips look good, and the fastening unit is rather complex in shape. But at the same time, it is suitable for only two types of fastening: for a hook and a flat pin without protruding latches, and it seems that there is no provision for changing the only double adapter.
| Model | Design | Weight, g | Edge length, mm | Working edge coating | Changeable adapter | Country | Price, rub |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch AeroTwin | Frameless | 94 | 393 | n.d. | Yes | Germany - China | 800 |
| Valeo first | Frameless | 79 | 400 | n.d. | Yes | France - Indonesia | 580 |
| Denso wiper blade | Hybrid | 127 | 402 | graphite | No | Netherlands - Korea | 575 |
| Champion winter | Frame in a case | 112 | 410 | graphite | Yes | USA | 510 |
| MegaPower Winter | frame in a case | 182 | 402 | fluoroplastic | No. One to 2 types of mounts | Russia - China | 460 |
Put on and take off
Traditionally, we start evaluating brushes with installation and removal exercises. The Valeo snapped and then disconnected most easily. And, if it is not difficult to put all the tested brushes with your hands in thick gloves, then it is only convenient to remove them without exposing your fingers. Despite the more complex fixing unit with the lid, the MegaPower didn’t cause much trouble either. Nevertheless, the cover and the thin latch tongue require the gloves to be removed first when removing the brush. The Denso mechanism of a similar design turned out to be tighter, which greatly complicates both removal and installation, especially when snow is packed inside the adapter. But they keep them tighter, practically without backlash. It is even more difficult to shoot Bosch, which requires precise synchronized finger pressure on the clasp on both sides. But at the same time they put on very easily - no more difficult than Valeo. The Champion turned out to be the most capricious in terms of installation, despite the simplest design of the fastening unit. Due to the tight fit on the wiper arm, the adapter holds on it more firmly than on the wiper - and remains on the arm when removed. And all would be fine, but after installation, you need to make sure that the adapter does not jump off the lever - otherwise, during operation, the brush may slide off it at the most inopportune moment, or even fly away altogether. But when the adapter is fastened properly, Champion holds firmly and practically does not play.
Denso wiper blade
Valeo first
Bosch Aerotwin
Champion winter
Mega power
Liquid and solid water
All the subjects easily coped with the task of brushing off the liquid from the glass surface to be cleaned in one full pass. Moreover, this time there was less water than in a similar summer test. On the one hand, downpour like a wall in our area in winter is almost unbelievable, at best (or worst) it will be a dull drizzle. On the other hand, watering with a hose in a fifteen-degree frost adds unreasonable difficulties to the testing process, including with an objective assessment of the result. Therefore, an anti-freeze liquid is evenly applied from a spray bottle to the entire surface of the windshield. We pour without stinginess until it begins to flow in abundant streams. The lever of the wipers in the position of a single stroke - and we look at the result. But there is nothing to compare: to our surprise, everyone is equally clean, without streaks, traces and stripes. Fine!
Now we complicate the task. The brushes were perfectly clean - they will be in the snow. After the first task, we dip the subjects into a snowdrift for a while, take them out, examine them and, without shaking them off, put them into work: we make a single sweep on the clean glass. After swimming in the snow, frozen snowflakes remained on all the brushes. Denso has the most, as the snow clogged under the spoiler, the least of all for both frame models - Champion and MegaPower. As a result, only these two pairs are not left behind on the glass. The other three models left approximately the same minimum wet streaks. At the same time, quite unexpectedly, Denso, having collected the most snow, gave even slightly fewer stripes than frameless competitors.
Ice test
We develop the icing theme further. Sometimes, after a wet thaw, the cold comes abruptly - and the windshield is covered with an ice crust. Likewise, the brushes also freeze up, even if they are thrown away from the windshield. But their tendency to icing is different: ice glaze sticks to different materials in different ways, even if they are all called by the general word "rubber". For clarity, we send the wet brushes to the freezer, where -20 ° C. And the next day we take it out, and, having isolated it from home heat, we take it outside, where it is -10 ° C. We unfold, study the ice, paying attention to the preservation of the elasticity of the mechanism and the icing of the working edge. And what? The MegaPower edge froze the least - there was almost no ice on it. Well, it is not for nothing that fluoroplastic is often used in industry as an anti-icing coating. The graphite turned out to be less resistant: the rest of the brushes got more frozen on the working edge, but also in different ways. To a lesser extent for Bosch and Champion, a little more for Valeo. But the worst thing about icing was Denso. These brushes were the only ones in which the ice disturbed the correct operation of the hinges, which made the whole mechanism lose its flexibility and elasticity. During the experiment, Denso became icy inside, which means that if they were standing on the car, they would have to be cleaned for a long time or even removed and warmed up.
Like snow on your head
The hardest test for winter brushes is the heavy snowfall. And if you often drive along narrow forest paths, then there are snowdrifts falling from the trees, when the roof of a tall car clings to low hanging heavy branches. So, we are imitating snow ... with the help of snow. Throw it liberally over the windshield, trying to distribute the white cover as evenly as possible. The warmed-up engine is running, and the saloon stove blows from the inside onto the glass at the second fan speed out of four possible. This maintains an optimal temperature on the outer surface: the snow cover slowly melts and tries to start sticking to the cold brushes. Again, one sweep - and we look at the result. If it is not clean enough, we continue to rub, counting the strokes.
Denso wiper blade
Valeo first
Bosch Aerotwin
Champion winter
Mega power
In some ways, this experiment resembled the autumn exercise with wet mud. Here, too, in order to get an objective result, I had to repeat the same thing several times with each pair of brushes and track the trend. The results of each specific measurement were influenced by how the snow was thrown onto the glass: it was physically impossible to achieve a uniform height and density of snow cover on the entire windshield, and even in every attempt it turned out to be physically impossible. Plus, in the course of the work, it turned out that the results were greatly aggravated by solid frozen snow drifts of snow removed from the glass, which were stuffed at the base of the wipers during the experiment. They simply squeeze the levers away from the glass, reducing the pressing force of the brushes. Therefore, for an objective assessment, we had to remove these frozen clods every time - and, in the end, we achieved reliable repeatability of the results, which allows us to draw conclusions. The brushes did the best with the task from the first sweep. Bosch- almost always perfectly clean, with minimal marks and drips. Others required at least two passes for the same cleanliness. After the first time Valeo, Champion and Denso left small wet stripes and spots, diluted a little more moisture MegaPower... The second swing changes the picture once again: MegaPower is rehabilitated, bringing the glass to almost ideal condition and Denso leaves it dry at all. But the Champion's progress is less pronounced - it still leaves thin wet streaks. But Valeo's result is even worse: these brushes, in addition to stripes, leave wet spots, so they need three strokes for a glass dry comparable to competitors.
There was a blizzard ...
Bench tests left a lot of reason for thought, identifying the leading models among competitors, but showing a relatively small spread of results in all exercises between the first and the last. Field trials during travel in all manifestations of winter weather gave our test lively details.
Pushkin very accurately called this state of the weather - "there was a blizzard." Just now everything was clean and almost clear, light snowflakes in the air were melting in small drops on the glass - and now everything was clouded with a white shroud, and heavy flakes of snow seem to rush towards you in a continuous dense stream. The wipers do not have time to cope with the volumes of the lying snow, and it does not have time to melt from the warm glass ... Soon a dense ice crust freezes in the corners and on the brushes themselves. It is becoming more and more and is typed on all models, including Bosch, about which it is officially written that the ice does not freeze to them.
But, despite this, all winter brushes do their job very well. Not without streaks and streaks, but they continue to keep the glass clear for safe driving in these most challenging winter conditions. Sometimes, however, quite rarely, all subjects require shaking off the accumulating ice - as a rule, it falls off on its own before it begins to noticeably spoil the work of the janitors. According to our observations, how quickly the ice freezes and how firmly the ice sticks, in practice, depends primarily on the weather and, to a lesser extent, on the model of brushes. But in any conditions Champion and MegaPower are the best at self-cleaning of adhered ice during operation. The fact is that these sheathed models have a higher working edge and more flexible than all the others.
However, even Denso passed the blizzard test very well, despite the semi-open design of the hinge-spring mechanism. Their spoiler turned out to be surprisingly effective - on the go, the snow almost did not clog into the frame. And even in the parking lot, when, after a heavy snowfall, the brushes were completely covered with a layer of snow, all their hinges remained mobile. The main thing is that at this time there are no transitions of the ambient temperature back and forth through zero.
In a thaw on a busy highway with a dirty suspension over the road, which stretches in a train behind each truck, the janitors have to work almost incessantly. And here it is no easier for them than in a blizzard. In addition, from time to time you have to use a washer - otherwise, dirt accumulates on the working edge and traces begin to remain.
Even so, perfection is not easy: too much water - left brush on reverse course drags it along a few centimeters along its entire height, too little water - dirty stripes appear. And so for all models. But with a slight difference in results: in such conditions, Bosch and Denso brushes work cleaner than others, Valeo and MegaPower do a little worse, and Champion stripes more than others.
However, while the brushes are new, the difference in results was not so great. But we tested them, periodically alternating, all winter - and by the spring the differences gradually began to become more distinct. Although, we must pay tribute, not a single model gave up ahead of time. So you can be sure that any of our test kits should be enough for the season.
Outcome
The differences in the effectiveness of the new brushes, according to the results of winter tests, were not very large. And the direct dependence of quality on price was violated. However, the most expensive model Bosch Aero Tween deservedly took first place in the total results of all tests - and it can be safely recommended to those who care less about the price. Unexpectedly, the Denso hybrid brushes performed very well, the design of which, it would seem, is not well suited for winter. You can safely “forget” to change their clothes after the summer season - and they will continue to work as if nothing had happened. Therefore, the Valeo frameless model, which is close in price, is simply devoid of economic sense, since in most tests it lost to the "hybrid". Champion also surrendered his champion positions: in a blizzard with large snow flakes, he does his job well, but the mud suspended in the air is hard for him. Under the same conditions, the cheaper closed MegaPowers behave, at least, not worse, and sometimes even better. And in general, according to the results of current tests, they show the best value for money.
No matter how new and modern your car is, safety in low visibility conditions largely depends on something as simple as the wiper blades. At untimely replacement road visibility deteriorates and there is a risk of road accidents. But it also happens that completely new brushes leave marks and stains on the glass, do not adhere well enough to the glass. Often the wipers fail winter season, frost and temperature changes lead to the loss of rubber properties. It is clear that any motorist would like, without spending too much, to purchase brushes that will do their job well for a long time. Rating according to Mark.guru will help you choose best brushes wiper among different types of designs.
Before making a purchase, review the following characteristics:
- Construction type... All wipers are divided into frame, frameless and hybrid. Each has its own pros and cons, so you need to figure out which one is best for you.
- Fastening. Some models have adapters for different types in the kit, but there are also those that are suitable only for a certain mount.
- The size. Depends on the make of the car, select so that the wipers do not touch each other during operation, but also clean a sufficient area of the glass.
- Manufacturer. Brushes from well-known manufacturers will last longer than cheap Chinese ones, but on condition that they are not a fake or a defect.
- Seasonality. There are universal options, but you can purchase it for a specific season. Elastic band for wipers of such models is softer and does not lose its properties at low temperatures.
- The price and quality of the material. As a rule, these are interdependent parameters. You will hardly be able to accurately determine the workmanship when the brush is in the package. But if the price is too low, treat the product more carefully, it would be good to listen to the reviews of those who have already bought wipers in this store.
Frame wiper blades
This is the cheapest option and is designed to provide the best fit for the rubber wiper blade to the glass. Fitting is provided by movable metal rocker arms on hinges.
In modern windshield wipers, the axles are usually plastic for better performance in cold weather and less icing. The disadvantage of this type of brushes is low wear resistance.
Firstly, they are poorly suited for winter, freezing and icing of metal parts occurs. Secondly, in case of poor-quality performance, the moving elements loosen, the geometry is disturbed, as a result of which the rubber strip is deformed and cannot cope with cleaning the glass.
This is a model of the French company Valeo, which produces components primarily for European cars. BMW, Mercedes, Volvo and Audi assembled in Europe are produced with wipers of this brand. The assortment is wide the lineup, can be selected by size or by car model, are made for a standard "hook" fastening.
The brushes have high quality workmanship and materials. Rubber behaves well even in winter conditions. Hardening in the cold, after warming up the car, elasticity and softness are not lost. When using, there is no squeak, streaks.
The model has a rubber wear indicator, so you know exactly when to buy new brushes.
This model is positioned as the quietest due to its low coefficient of friction. The frame is securely attached to the rubber at six points. The base of the plate is very high, which completely eliminates the contact between the frame and glass.
- quality materials and assembly;
- snug fit;
- silent work;
- resistance to wear.
Cons: there are no adapters for other types of fastening included.
The average price of a set of two brushes is 1800 rubles.
Prices :
In second place is the famous and popular German model Bosch Twin. They are also made for hook fastening. The brushes are thin and flexible, and the rubber edge is quite stiff, which results in faster wear. The narrow working part of the brush also tends to warp over time. On the other hand, Bosch brushes handle dirt and slush well. The metal rocker arms of the frame hold the rubber base at five points; there are additionally plastic inserts at the joints.
Interestingly, the metal plate is located inside the elastic, and not outside, as in most frame models.
- high-quality cleaning;
- snug fit;
- easy installation thanks to the Quick-Clip adapter.
Cons: wear out quickly.
The average price for a set is 1,700 rubles.
Prices :
The third place in the rating of frame brushes is the German model Heyner Exclusive. The metal frame is fully galvanized, the spring is made of stainless steel. The brush has good aerodynamics, providing good pressure and full performance even at high speeds. There is even a special anti-reflective coating housing.
The model has a wide range of sizes, hook fastening. But you can purchase an adapter separately, which will allow you to use the wipers on almost any car model.
In addition, the design assumes the possibility of replacing the cleaning rubber for the brushes, which allows some savings on replacement. But this is also weak side models, since the collapsible structure creates the risk of delamination of the wiper in frost, when the rubber part freezes to the glass.
- low price;
- high-quality cleaning;
- snug fit at any speed;
- the ability to use an adapter for other types of mounts.
Cons: freezing to glass in winter, risk of delamination of the structure.
The average price is 800 rubles per set.
Prices :
4. Champion Aerovantage
A feature of the brush is a completely metal body design, as well as a universal connector that allows the model to be used on different types of mounts.
Spring connections at the base of the frame ensure a snug fit to the glass, the brushes are lightweight and quiet enough.
- high quality rubber element;
- smoothness of work;
- universal mount.
Cons: Tendency to loosen the hinge structure.
Champion Aerovantage Prices:
Frameless models
In such wipers, the cleaning rubber strip is attached to two thin metal plates, and the entire structure is housed in a flexible plastic case.
At the same time, the tightness of adhesion to the glass is somewhat lower than that of frame models, but such wipers are not susceptible to icing in frost and work great in any weather.
They cost a little more than models with a metal frame.
1. Denso Flat Blade
The best frameless model of steel brushes from Japanese company Denso Flat Blade. Their high performance they show primarily due to their excellent aerodynamics. The thin cleaning edge and flexible base provide excellent water, dirt and slush removal without smudges or streaks. The brushes work smoothly and silently, literally sticking to the glass and cleaning it dry.
The model has a universal mount, an anti-freeze frame allows you to use them in any weather.
- effective work;
- good glass cleaning even at high speed;
- easy installation.
Cons: short service life.
The average price is 1,300 rubles per set.
Denso Flat Blade prices:
Excellent frameless wipers from a French manufacturer, but at a very high price. Plus, it's the same traditional hook-and-loop fastener that won't fit all cars. But the execution of the model is simply excellent. The rubber material used is the same as in the frame model of the rating, namely, it has exceptional softness, elasticity and wear resistance.
In addition, the design has improved aerodynamic characteristics, providing accelerated deflation of the water removed by the brush with a stream of air.
There is also a proprietary color-coded wear indicator.
- quality material and workmanship;
- good performance when driving at high speed;
- durability.
- high price;
- there is no adapter for other types of mounts.
The average price for a set is 1900 rubles.
Prices :
In the segment of frameless models, the German Bosch Aerotwin took only third place. Their advantage is also good aerodynamics, which is what determines a snug fit to the glass. At the same time, water, dirt, snow are removed qualitatively. Even on dry glass, they glide smoothly and without squeaks.
Silicone is added to the rubber, which makes the brushes soft and resilient, making it easy to use in cold weather.
It is also worth noting the presence of a universal mount in the model, which makes it easy to install wipers on a variety of cars.
- high-quality cleaning;
- frost resistance;
- universal mount;
- wear resistance.
Cons: the risk of scratching the glass with metal fasteners due to deformation or wear of the rubber part.
The average price for a set is 1200 rubles.
Prices :
Hybrid brushes
Hybrid brushes combine all the advantages of the previous two types. They have a metal frame that ensures good grip of the elastic to the glass, but it is hidden in a special plastic casing. It prevents both contamination of the frame elements and icing in frost. Plus, good aerodynamics allows them to fully cope with their tasks when driving at high speed. The only drawback of this type of brushes is their high price.
1. Heyner Hybrid Graphit
This model is distinguished by high quality rubber with a special graphite coating. It allows you to achieve smooth, quiet operation. This variant of the best hybrid wipers reflects all the advantages of the design. Excellent aerodynamics, stylish design, well thought-out frame, pressing the brush tightly to the glass.
At the same time, the plastic cover reliably protects metal elements from moisture and low temperatures.
Heyner Hybrid Graphit is great for any weather.
- high-quality cleaning;
- suitable for different types of fastening;
- good value for money.
Cons: deteriorates in cold weather.
The average price is 900 rubles per set.
Prices for Heyner Hybrid Graphit:
2. Denso Hybrid Wiper Blade
The Japanese model of hybrid brushes features a special springy frame. It allows the cleaning edge to fit snugly against the glass. The working surface is graphite coated and has a long service life. The case with a stylish matte finish reliably protects the frame from dust and dirt.
This model shows high performance both in frosty weather and in hot sun conditions.
Advantages:
- long service life;
- good work in all weather conditions;
- universal mount;
- easy installation.
No flaws were found in the model.
Denso Hybrid Wiper Blade pricing:
In third place are the premium hybrid brushes Trico Hybrid. They are lightweight and quiet. Structurally, they are very similar to the popular Denso Hybrid.
Teflon is included in the rubber of the brushes. It allows you to maintain all performance characteristics in any weather and season.
Advantages:
- high-quality cleaning;
- good aerodynamics;
- noiselessness.
Disadvantages: substandard fakes are often found.
The average price is 1400 rubles per set.
Prices :
Conclusion
This is the rating best models wiper blades of different designs. To make the right choice, first decide on the type of wipers, then select the model. After evaluating all the criteria, you can choose the best price-performance ratio for yourself. Remember that the most expensive models, for example, from Valeo, will last more than one year, and the cheaper ones may have to be replaced in a few months. Also, if you have a standard hook mount, then you shouldn't overpay for models with included adapters. The best choice is always individual, and the ratings only help to make a decision.
